Analyst Gene Munster gives Apple's Siri a grade D for accuracy

03.07.2012
Piper Jaffray analyst Gene Munster has put Siri to the test, asking his iPhone 1,600 questions in total to find out how accurate the 4S's personal assistant is.

that Munster split the questions into two halves, asking 800 on a busy street and 800 in a quiet room. Munster then published his results in a note to clients on Thursday.

When testing Google, the search engine understood 100 per cent of the typed in questions and replied accurately 86 per cent of the time, earning a B+ from the analyst.

understood 83 per cent of the queries in noisy conditions, and 89 per cent in a quiet room. Siri gave an accurate reply 62 per cent of the time on the busy streets and 68 per cent in a quiet environment. This earned Siri a grade D for accuracy, according to Munster.

"In order to become a viable mobile search alternative, Siri must match or surpass Google's accuracy of B+ and move from a grade D to a B or higher," wrote Munster.

The release of iOS 6 this autumn and the decrease in reliance on Google could help Siri catch up, said Munster, who believes that the iPhone's assistant is two years behind Google in its .