TomTom suit shows Microsoft's split personality

26.02.2009
Microsoft has been vocal about its interest in working more closely with the open-source community in the past couple of years, actively promoting interoperability, forging new relationships and donating code to open-source projects. But the patent-infringement suit it filed Wednesday against TomTom has the Linux community, in particular, concerned that Microsoft is only paying lip service to its new approach and plans to continue to threaten Linux distributors with patent-infringement claims.

Microsoft on Wednesday filed suit against the GPS navigational device maker, alleging it is infringing eight patents, some of which involve technologies found in a version of the Linux OS that TomTom's portable devices run.

Microsoft maintains the suit has nothing to do with Linux itself but is a specific disagreement between the two companies over specific technologies.

"We took this action after trying -- in good faith -- for more than a year to resolve this matter with TomTom," said Microsoft spokesman Michael Marinello in an e-mail Thursday. He said Alpine Electronics of America, Kenwood U.S.A., Pioneer Electronics (USA) and other companies already license the technology in question from Microsoft.

Still, because the patent-infringement suit involves Linux -- which Microsoft executives two years ago violates more than 235 patents the company holds -- the news has made the Linux community uneasy and distrustful of Microsoft once again.

Moreover, it's a reversal of a friendlier attitude toward open source that Microsoft has tried to cultivate with the formation of its Platform Strategy Group a little more than a year ago. The mission of that group, in part, is aimed at reversing the message of Microsoft's infamous "Get the Facts" campaign of several years ago. That campaign aggressively tried to show customers the value proposition of deploying a Windows environment instead of Linux.