Proposed New York Legislation Would Ban Anonymous Online Comments

24.05.2012
Online anonymity is once again under attack. This time, it comes from the New York state Senate floor, where is bill is aiming to cut down on cyberbullying, protect small businesses, and -naturally - protect politicians from anonymous attacks during campaign season.

This amendment would, were it approved (which it won't be, so don't worry), require New York-based websites to , unless said users agree to attach their names to said comments.

And this isn't some wishy-washy , either -- you can't just offer up a real-sounding name to attach to your comment and be done with it. According to the text of the bill, the anonymous poster must agree to attach his or her name to the post and "confirm that his or her IP address, legal name, and home address are accurate." Technically, that even makes my byline sketchy, since my legal name is just Sarah Purewal.

Websites would be required to place a contact number or email address "clearly visible" in any place where comments can be posted. And no, in case you're wondering -- the person who requests that an anonymous comment be taken down does not have to disclose their IP address, legal name, or home address.

The legislation is sponsored by Assemblyman Dean Murray (R - East Patchogue) and Senator Thomas O'Mara (R - Big Flats). Again, according to the sponsors, the act will help to cut down on cyberbullying, protect small businesses such as restaurants from unfounded, negative reviews, and, naturally, protect politicians from baseless, derogatory attacks during campaign time. I'm sure that last concern is only an afterthought.

Now, this is not to say that I condone online bullying or libelous comments. But cracking down on the premier form of free speech -- that is, anonymous speech -- is not exactly the way to combat either of these things. As points out, how well would the anonymously-written have worked out, had Alexander Hamilton, James Madison, and John Jay been required to confirm their IP addresses, legal names, and home addresses?